Mac Extreme Dimension Or Benefits They're Real?

Dec 15, 2013

Gemma T.

Hi ladies. Was wondering if anyone has tried both these mascaras and which one they recommend? I am currently wearing they're real but I'm a mac girl at heart and am always looking for something better x

Dec 15, 2013

Linda A.

I've used both and the extreme dimension is in my opinion soooo much better! the brush design does need some improvement as it really deposits almost too much on the first coat. the formula however is far superior to they're real and it is my hg mascara. I only need one coat and I also use a clean spoolie to to separate the excess, but I love the self curling formula.

Dec 16, 2013

Meg T.

I love mac. My mac collection is out of control. Easily 65% of my makeup collection but, their mascaras always let me down. I didn't like extreme dimension. Clumpy, didn't separate my lashes. I was hoping once the formula dried a bit it would apply nicer but, it didn't. I loved zoom lash and the extended play gigablack mascara. The extended play mascara is in my top three favorites of any brand mascara.
They're real was good. I liked it, didn't repurchase it. I think mascara is such a personal thing. It is the one makeup product that every person can have a different opinion on.

Dec 16, 2013

Kathryn L.

Never tried the Mac mascara but really quite like benefits they're real.

Dec 17, 2013

Frances D.

I don't like mac or benefit mascaras.

Dec 17, 2013

Linda A.

Hi Frances...I'm curious what is it you don't like about them? Which mascara do you prefer?

Previous topic

Day out motd!

Dec 17, 2013
7

Next topic

Concealer tips please

Dec 17, 2013
10

Gemma T.

2 Photos

Good Molecules: See a difference in your skin

New Arrivals

Forum Rules

Please help us maintain positive conversations here by following our guidelines below.

We reserve the right to remove comments and topics that don't adhere to the following rules. We also may remove the profile of any repeat offender. Thanks for reading and contributing!

Be Kind

Beautylish is a diverse, positive, and respectful community. It’s okay to disagree with someone, but be constructive—not rude. We have a zero-tolerance policy for negativity and harassment.

Contribute Thoughtfully

Take the time to make posts easy to understand by using proper spelling, grammar, and capitalization. Post topics in the appropriate category and refrain from making duplicate posts. Know that we don't allow self-promotion, advertisements, spam, commercial messages, or links to other websites or blogs. And be careful that you don't post someone else's work and present or claim it as your own.

We reserve the right to remove duplicate, miscategorized, and difficult-to-understand posts, or those we deem as advertisements, spam, or plagiarism.

Be Vigilant

Use the flag button to report inappropriate or disrespectful behavior, or email us at help@beautylish.com.