Barbara D.
Barbara D.

Beauty Product Reviews

Make-Up Atelier Gel Eyeliner

Smudge-O-Rama

I usually use Bobbi Brown gel liner, which is great, but I wanted a liner that really, really doesn't budge. I thought I'd try Makeup Atelier since Wayne Goss mentioned in a YouTube video that this one stayes put because it containes wax. In fact, it is very, very soft and smudged within an hour of application; in spite of my using the WG tight lining brush to keep it at the base of my lashes and just a tiny bit into the water line it transferred all the way from my upper lid crease to 1/2" below my lower lash line! If I wanted the Heroin Chic look, this would be the product for me. I don't, so it's back to my old tried and true Bobbi Brown for now.