Gel Eyeliner

I live in a country where it’s extremely hot and humid (34 degrees) and I’m outdoors a lot. This eyeliner stays on, doesn’t budge or smudge. I wear this over eye primer and it costs less than my MAC gel fluid line. Will definitely purchase again!

Got this based on a recommendation from Wayne Goss video. I had tried every eyeliner that was supposed to stay but had no luck with my watery eyes. Used this on my upper waterline and did not smudge onto my bottom nor run down my face, just stayed put. Very enthused to be able to line my upper water line :)

I really love it for my top lid. It doesn't flake and is not expensive. Give it a minute to dry . The other reviewer did not like it but I guess it boils down to how your skin reacts to the product.

I usually use Bobbi Brown gel liner, which is great, but I wanted a liner that really, really doesn't budge. I thought I'd try Makeup Atelier since Wayne Goss mentioned in a YouTube video that this one stayes put because it containes wax. In fact, it is very, very soft and smudged within an hour of application; in spite of my using the WG tight lining brush to keep it at the base of my lashes and just a tiny bit into the water line it transferred all the way from my upper lid crease to 1/2" below my lower lash line! If I wanted the Heroin Chic look, this would be the product for me. I don't, so it's back to my old tried and true Bobbi Brown for now.