Best Mascara

19

Sort By

Lots of mascaras claim they're smudge proof but lots of them prove otherwise!! Ha! But what mascara out there are really smudge proof and glides nice and smooth like silk? I'm constantly searching! Help!

Dec 2, 2012

Lizzette G.

Great lash by maybelline waterproof!! 

Dec 2, 2012

Reilly G.

maybelline cat eyes

Dec 2, 2012

Gabrielle N.

NYX Pin up tease is amazing

thanks guys! they're reasonably priced too! i appreciate it!

Dec 2, 2012

Jessie W.

i would recommend Benefit's They Are REAL!

sounds good! thanks!

Dec 2, 2012

Jenna S.

Avon Super Extend, more people need to try it! 

Dec 2, 2012

Jessie W.

here's pic of Benefit's They Are REAL mascara :D

Dec 2, 2012

Imane A.

i have a similar issue...my eyes tear a lot in winter! Benefit "they're real" ($22) works for me and so does e.l.f's studio lengthening and volumizing mascara ($3) 

Dec 2, 2012

Peyton O.

Mary Kay, it's a super water proof one. It's amazing!! It's truly the best mascara I've ever used!  

Dec 2, 2012

Mariah W.

Two faced! The extra large brush. It's not waterproof and works great! 

Dec 2, 2012

Maxine D.

the magic is ALL IN THE BRUSH and the QUALITY of the mascara it self.. if found many mascaras that either have excellent brushes but garbage mascara or the opposite. the BEST brushes r the PLASTIC ones preferably long bristles those other brushes r trash 

Dec 2, 2012

Lindsay C.

I love Benedict's They're Real! I wear mascara for about 15 hours a day and it lasts without crumbling. Awesome!

Smashbox hyper lash, GIVENCHY, Mac dimensions, hypnose star, Mac zoom lash

Dec 2, 2012

Emm N.

Defiantly the falsies range!

Thanks guys! Love the suggestions! I just got a mascara from Walmart...Ginormous Lashes by Hard Candy...doesn't really make ur lashes ginormous but it applies smoothly and it doesn't smudge! yay! i think i love it. but i'll also try some of the suggestions here. Like the popular They're Real by Benefit :)

Dec 8, 2012

Camry S.

HANDS DOWN DIORSHOW BLACKOUT. it's all I use, I haven't left the house without it in about 3 years lol. The primer is good too :) 

Dec 8, 2012

Magdalena A.

Maybelline The Colossal Volum' in both 100% Black and Black Waterproof. Amazing and does wonders with my lashes.

Dec 8, 2012

Nayrouz J.

I use Lash blast volume by covergirl and Effet liner effect by Bourjois  

Dec 8, 2012

Lauryn L.

I think the Maybelline New York (the mega plush volume, very black) is the best mascara

Dec 9, 2012

Liza G.

OK here is my mascara bin. I've tried everything on the market pretty much. first I suggest a waterproof formula as that will be less prone to smudging. I like Urban Decay Cannonball. I also recommend a lash primer as it will help the formula stay on your lashes longer without migrating where it shouldn't. if you can't do waterproof or a primer, some regular formulas I like are Tarte lights, camera lashes, Guerlain Noir and Ecco Bella Flower Color 

Dec 9, 2012

Tina H.

Buxom is my favorite or DiorShow!

thanks girls! these are helpful!

Hahaha! Liza C. ur addicted!