Most overrated and underrated.
32
- NEW: Earn free store credit with Beautylish Rewards.
- Ship To: | EN
-
Contact Us
Our customer service team in the US is ready to assist you.
Monday - Friday
7 AM – 4 PM PTSaturday
7 AM – 4 PM PT
- Login
- Join
- Your Bag 0
Mar 29, 2014
Brianna M.
What makeup brands do you guys think are most overrated and underrated?
Mar 29, 2014
Symone B.
Underrated: Bh cosmetics (Coastal scents is the same company too)
Mar 29, 2014
Lou C.
I think MAC lipsticks are overrated- I don't like them. They don't stay on very long and the colours aren't that great either imo.. I don't get the hype about them.
And I agree with Symone: bh cosmetics eyeshadow palettes are awesome- definitely an underrated brand :)
Mar 29, 2014
Lauren F.
Most overrated is MAC deffo, look I'm not paying lots for foundations that I can get cheaper anyway!
Mar 29, 2014
Leamsy R.
I actually think BH cosmetics is overrated! They are not as great as everyone makes them out to be 😒
Mar 29, 2014
Leamsy R.
I also think wet n wild is overrated! I hate their lipsticks 😩
Mar 29, 2014
Effy W.
Overrated: MAC
Underrated: Sephora brand
Mar 29, 2014
Amanda V.
Underrated
Bare Minerals: loose shadows, lip gloss, etc. I never tried the powder foundations though.
Kat von D: Used to be underrated. I had multiple palettes when the brand first launched. Although it seemed to become increasingly popular after the foundation debuted.
Wet n' Wild: I'm new to this brand but I understand why it's a cult favorite. The eyeshadows are insanely pigmented!
I'll have to think about the overrated brands.
Mar 29, 2014
Amanda V.
Oh & Sephora Collection is definitely underrated!
Their eyeshadows are not the best but they reformulated so they have improved!
I really love the lipgloss and lipstick as well.
I think the best thing about this brand is that they have such a wide selection of products and colors!
Mar 29, 2014
Amanda V.
Ahhh Jacqlyn I forgot Clinique!
Mar 29, 2014
Calla I.
Overrated- Kat Von d liner, loreal, beauty blender, mac face products
Underrated- physicians formula, tarte concealer, Olay, lip smackers, benefit bad gal
Mar 29, 2014
Hannah K.
Overrated brands, to me, are Mac (I like one thing. One. And it's not even their lipsticks. Their lipsticks are drying, not very pigmented, and don't last longer than an hour, even if I don't eat anything), Elf (everyone raves about how it's great for being so cheap, but almost all products I've tried from them are absolute junk), Benefit (yeah, the packaging is cute, but nothing I have from them is worth the price in the slightest), Vaseline brand (stuff is crap. Petroleum jelly doesn't do anything for anyone, it doesn't moisturize, and it can clog pores and ruin your skin, no matter where you use it).
Underrated Brands: Buxom (it's absolutely amazing, I haven't tried a thing from them that I dislike, their products are so pigmented and pretty and easy to apply. I especially love their cream shadows, I have every color), True Blue Spa (has great lotions! Amazing!), Fresh (everything is good, seriously. Lip balms, face wash, everything), Korres (I haven't disliked a single thing I've tried from them), Butter London nail polish (it's expensive, but worth it. Really, it's the best nail polish I've tried, no chipping or peeling at all).
Mar 30, 2014
Hannah K.
Overrated - MAC and L'Oreal.
Underrated - BareMinerals, Liz Earle. Both are amazing!
Mar 30, 2014
Stephanie S.
Mac-
wet and wild, avon (:
Mar 30, 2014
Lexi K.
I agree with Leamsy, bh, coastal scents, crown, all those mega 120/88 eyeshadow palettes are hyped up and actually such mediocre quality.. Once you experience a good quality eyeshadow, you can't turn back lol.
Mar 30, 2014
Haley G.
Overrated: loreal skincare (alcohol city!) and face products, OPI polish, MAC in general
Underrated: agree with hannah, buxom is AMAZING. KvD used to be underrated , but still fab. Milani, jordana (owned by the same company, I think), hard candy nail polish, rimmel, essence, and prestige cosmetics. Especially prestige!
Mar 30, 2014
Aileen L.
Overrated- Deff Mac (way too expensive)! I have four lippies and they are very dry I say perfect if you want matt, Naked palletes (I'm afraid to buy one coz of the money)
Underrated- BareMinerals, Olay, bh cosmetics eyeshadow palette & lastly proffessional 120 eyeshadow palette (They are so pigmented)
Mar 30, 2014
Anupa M.
Overrated: Urban Decay, MAC, coastal scents
Under rated: Rimmel, Profusion's eye shadows, Lacura :)
Mar 30, 2014
Cassandra H.
Underrated:The Balm and Stila
Overrated: Nars
Mar 30, 2014
Jenny F.
Physicians formula is underrated. I love they're bronzer/blushes. :)
Mar 30, 2014
Iva T.
BBCream maybelline.garnier.loreal. they. are worth to try. or Korean. BB creams. are flawless. experienced each of them.
Mar 30, 2014
Iva T.
So they are underrated.
Mar 30, 2014
Meagan M.
Overrated: naked 3, Mac lipsticks ( I wear them but they are overrated, essie,
Underrated: rimmel London lipsticks!
Mar 30, 2014
Jenna M.
I will 100% stand by the naked palletes! They are not overrated!
Mar 30, 2014
Ashley D.
I think the most overrated brand of all time is MAC. Its honestly not that great and there are tons of underrated brands that are a billion times better.