Which One U Think Is Better Liquid Or Pencil Eye Liner???

29

Sort By

Dec 27, 2012

Jocy J.

Which one is better pencil or liquid eye liner???:/

Dec 27, 2012

Payton K.

I prefer liquid eye liner but thats just me(:

Dec 27, 2012

Jocy J.

Ibe never tried liquid wats the difference??

Dec 27, 2012

Victoria P.

Liquid is more precise and gives a cleaner shaper looking appearance :)

Dec 27, 2012

Yesenia P.

Liquid!!

Dec 27, 2012

Emily C.

They both have their ups and downs, liquid eyeliner is a little harder to control than pencil eye liner. But pencil eye liner also smudges easier than liquid. So it's really just up to you:)

Dec 27, 2012

Tonita C.

What Victoria said! 

Dec 27, 2012

Jocy J.

Okayy thankz!:D

Dec 27, 2012

Allison W.

I like liquid because its easier to fill in that little bit of skin that can sometimes show between your lash line and where you line... Perhaps this is an over 30 thing:) but pencil looks more natural, liquid looks more stylized overall!

Dec 27, 2012

Cristina S.

I prefer gel liner but it really depends what look I'm going for. If I'm going for a more casual look, I'll use pencil and if it's a night look I usualy would opt for liquid :)

Dec 27, 2012

Manasi S.

liquid for the top and pencil for the bottom for me

Dec 27, 2012

Sheena B.

I like both but for a quick look for work I just tight line and line the water line with a pencil. 

Dec 27, 2012

Jocy J.

Thankz . Ithinkk imm gonna see hooww i look with the liquid eye liner!:)

Dec 27, 2012

Aisha K.

Liquid! :) ❤ 

Dec 27, 2012

Sydney P.

I think liquid just for top , but pencil for both top and bottom

Dec 27, 2012

Alli Rose G.

I use gel/cream eyeliner for wings and such. I like pencil eyeliners for bases and underneath my lash line. I hate liquid eyeliners. They irritate my eyes, and I like using a liner brush. 

Dec 27, 2012

Grace I.

Depends. I use pencil for my brows and mostly liquid for eyes

Dec 27, 2012

Christine K.

what Manasi said :)

Dec 27, 2012

Vanessa G.

Liquid on top lash line & gel or pencil on water line 

Dec 27, 2012

Raven N.

I used to use only pencils because liquid is harder to apply if you are just picking it up -- your first few times can be frustrating. But once I gave it a chance and some practice I ended up prefering that everyday. It just glides on a lot nicer, and doesn't smudge/need to be set. You just have to play with one and see whether you like it better (though a pencil is best for waterline). Try one with one of those felt tips because they are easier to practice with then a brush.

Dec 27, 2012

Z M.

Gel lol 

Dec 27, 2012

Myka D.

liquid.

Dec 27, 2012

Sarah B.

Liquid for the top, pencil for the bottom waterline! 

Dec 27, 2012

Lily W.

Pencil for day and both at night! I use pencil in the waterline for a subtle daytime look but for nighttime I add liquid on the top along with adding more pencil on the bottom

Dec 27, 2012

Brenda M.

Liquid, it looks more clean and lasts longer