Mac vs urban decay?

Oct 14, 2014

Nilam P.

Hi! I've been using Mac PowerPoint eyeliner pencil in "engraved" for the past few years on my waterline. I've recently heard good things about urban decay 24/7 liner in "perversion" though. Has anyone tried both? Which is better in terms of dark pigment and staying power? Thanks!

Oct 14, 2014

Hannah K.

Okay, I will give you a disclaimer before I start: I am NOT a Mac person.

I don't think that Mac pencils are particularly pigmented, and I actually also find them to be kind of hard and not very creamy.

That said, Perversion is the blackest, creamiest, most wonderful eyeliner that I've ever used. It is immovable once its set, it stays on the waterline wonderfully, and I really, truly just love it.

Oct 14, 2014

Shelley W.

I have both in my collection...UD hands down without a doubt has the best liners on the planet. And as Hannah mentioned Perversion is on point and is very user friendly while with some of MAC liners I have to really put in work to make it work.

Oct 14, 2014

Kathleen M.

I have to agree with both ladies! UD forsure.

Oct 15, 2014

Nilam P.

Thanks ladies! Perversion it is! X

Oct 15, 2014

Sim T.

Urban decay is the best, color selection wise, pigmentation wise, and lasting power. however, mac has better liquid liners. so, depends on what you're into! If you want gel, inglot is the way to go =)

Oct 15, 2014

Bronwyn R.

Urban decay perversion is AMAZING!!

Oct 15, 2014

Louise U.

Urban Decay everytime