Most Under and Overrated Products?
28
- Flexible Payments: Shop now. Pay later.
- Ship To: | EN
-
Contact Us
Our customer service team in the US is ready to assist you.
Monday - Friday
7 AM – 4 PM PTSaturday
7 AM – 4 PM PT
- Login
- Join
- Your Bag 0
Feb 4, 2014
Antonia S.
Title says it all. What do you think are the most over and underrated products?
In my opinion...
Overrated: Naked Palettes
Underrated: Wet and Wild Products (especially blushes. Far more pigmented than my MAC Blushes and cost me less than $2.)
I'd also like to know the best deal or bargain you've got on a beauty product.
Last week I ordered 12 full size foundations for $2.95 a bottle.
Feb 4, 2014
Mikayla B.
Underated products: my wet and wild eyeshadows, I chose them over my urban decay eyeshadows.
eyelash curler- seriously makes my eyelashes huge
overrated: the falsies, it made my eyelashes clumpy and super small
eos, waxy and non moisturizing
covergirl products period, I dislike them!
Feb 4, 2014
Calla I.
Overrated- mac powder (very cakey and unnatural)
Benetint (completely unbendable)
The rocket - super dry and clumpy
Underrated- physicians formula products
Jordana pencils
Nyx Creme blushes
Covergirl lengthening mascara
Feb 4, 2014
Kitty K.
Underrated : Foreo Luna, Wet n wild lipsticks. Lumene BB Cream, BareMinerals, Sulfur, L'oreal Infalliable shadows.
Overrated: Maybelline, Cover girl, Cargo, Naked Palettes, Loreal Lumi foundation.
Feb 4, 2014
Kitty K.
@Calla I was reading on a beauty blog the other day that the NYX Creme blushes were a good dupe for the Stila ones! I have one from Stila and I love it... I think I might get some from NYX now!
Feb 4, 2014
lexi P.
Overrated: Stila liquid liner
undderated: nyx blush
Feb 4, 2014
Hannah K.
Underrated: Nars lipsticks, Kat Von D eyeshadows, Elf Lip Scrub, Nivea Lip Butters, L'oreal Power Volume Collagen mascara, any and all lash primers, Physician's Formula Blushes
Overrated: Naked Palettes, Mac Lipsticks, Lush Lip Scrubs, Vaseline (seriously, it doesn't DO anything!!), Mac Blushes, Eos/Baby Lips, Benefit They're Real mascara
Feb 4, 2014
Meagan M.
Overrated: Essie nail polish only good thing is I love the colors. Lush bath bombs because they only made my skin soft for like an hour after the bath. And maybelline fit me foundation.
underrated: elf makeup brushes and primers. Nars lipsticks. Bare mineral blush and lipsticks. And there is more I can't think of more right now!
Feb 4, 2014
Calla I.
@Kitty yes they are really good!! Only like 6 dollars I think and the best Creme blush I've used :))
Feb 4, 2014
Cami F.
Underrated: Yves Saint Laurent Babydoll Lash, Stila Convertible Colors, L'Oreal Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Tarte Amazonian Clay 12 Hr Full Coverage Foundation, Covergirl Bombshell Mascara, Smashbox Master Class 2 Palette (amazing), Bare Minerals Eye Shadows, L'Oreal Magic Lumi Primer, and Benefit Brow Zings.
Overrated: Stila Liquid Eyeliner, Naked Palettes 1 and 2, Mac Mineralize Skinfinish, Benefit They're Real, Benetint, L'Oreal True Match, and EOS Lip Balms.
Feb 4, 2014
Beriah F.
Overrated: covergirl in general
Underrated: Almay get up and grow mascara
Feb 4, 2014
Tiril S.
Overrated: Mac lipsticks, eos, maybelline eyeshaddows, l'oreal lumi, Max factor and opi nail laquers.
Underrated: elf, rimmel general an sleek palettes
Feb 4, 2014
Caitlin M.
Overrated:
- MAC in general
- EOS and Babylips
- Vaseline (seriously it does nothing. I don't get why people still insist that it does...)
- Drugstore foundations. I never have any luck with them. They're always oily and just so gross.
- The Falsies mascara
- Naked/neutral eyeshadow palettes
- Bh eyeshadow. Seriously it's the worst shadow I've used. It doesn't blend well and is very chalky. I don't get the hype.
Underrated:
- Nyx
- Soap & Glory
- Elf lip exfoliator
- Rimmel Wake Me Up concealer
- Pacifica skincare/body butters
Feb 4, 2014
Hannah K.
Caitlin, part 2 of reading my mind? Lol.
Feb 4, 2014
Mary P.
Underated: elf, Nivea, Burt's bees, and Chapstick
Overrated: MAC, eos, babylips, and covergirl
Feb 4, 2014
Brianna W.
Overrated: anything MAC (they're good but seriously nothing special), eos lip eggs, l'oreal lumi foundation, anything covergirl, bare minerals
Underrated; NYX anything, Urban Decay B6 spray, Boscia skin care, coconut oil
Feb 4, 2014
Isabel M.
Overrated:
-Mac (agree with you ladies completely) I have found plenty of dupes for eyeshadows , lipsticks , blushes ECT.
-EOS , Babylips( utterly no moisture , totally waste of three dollars)
Benefits they're real, naked palettes,
Underrated:
Wet n wild( almost everything, granted a few products)
Nivea stuff is magical,
NYC big city curl mascara is fabulous for my eyelashes!! It makes them look gargantuan,
Rimmel lipsticks, and eyeliners,
Coconut oil,
Shea moisture products,
L'Oreal infallible gel liner
Feb 4, 2014
CPT- Lili R.
Overrated
1. Mac (good products but nothing to die for, the brushes are good though)
2. Elf brushes (there a piece of shit they shed more then a cat)
3.nyx eye primer pencile thing, that thing is so hard to use as a primer it creases and makes everything so difficult
4. Urban decays all nighter
Underrated
1.sonia kashuk brushes
2.lorac eye shadows
3. Ben nye products
4. Kevyn aucoin products
5. Milani products are decent and not that expensive
6. Nuance by salma hakey blush trio and cream eyeshadow trio and foundation
Feb 4, 2014
Isabel M.
Oh lord, Lili I can't believe I forgot Lorac, Sonia Kashuk, and Ben Nye! I haven't tried Nuance or Milani yet!
Feb 4, 2014
CPT- Lili R.
You should try them isabel 😊
Feb 4, 2014
CPT- Lili R.
Jackie the underrated products you listed sound so fancy I have never heard of them lol.
Feb 5, 2014
Lisa S.
Overated: Revlon Coloratay, L'Oreal True Match and True Match Lumi (I have tried them multiple times thinking they might be better but it doesn't work for my skin), Maybelline Falsies Mascara, Benefit Benetints, Girl Meets Pearl, and Whatts Up (never showed up on my skin), Makeup Forever HD Powder, Elf Shadow Primer, Lorac Palettes (I just have a really hard time making them show up on my eyes, I have to layer layer layer before anything shows up)
Underrated- Wet N' Wild Eyeshadows, Jordana, Eyeliner, some Elf products, Milani Eye Shadow Primer and Blushes
Feb 5, 2014
Nicola D.
I totally disagree about MAC I know some people really don't get on with their products but every product I have tried my skin has really agreed with!
Feb 5, 2014
Isabelle S.
Overrated: Benefit "They're Real"
Underrated: Jordana Eyeshadows, Tarte's Sweethearts Blush
Feb 5, 2014
Mackenzi B.
Overrated: where do I begin? A lot of maybelline products, mac eyeshadows, real techniques brushes, eos, "organic" makeup, naked palettes (don't get me wrong I love mine but it was not as amazing as everyone thinks)
Underrated: Clinique as a whole, physicians formula powders, wetnwild liquid lip colors and eyeshadow palettes,