Really good black eyeliner

34

Sort By

Dec 17, 2012

Amanda B.

I am in need of a new black eyeliner. The one I use right now is urban decay 24/7 but it seems to fall apart or break when I apply it or try to sharpen it. I really like how black it goes on though. Please help!

Dec 17, 2012

Allison W.

If you'll use a liquid eyeliner i suggest almay. it stays all day and doesnt smudge easy. idk i like it alot. :) 

Dec 17, 2012

Brittany S.

Revlon colorstay liquid liner. It's been my go to for years. 

Dec 17, 2012

Ebony C.

Revlon definately

Dec 17, 2012

Hayley P.

The MAC fluid line I'm black track is a great gel liner. For liquid liner I would suggest sephoras brand. It is really great with easy application! I'm not sure about pencil liners because I don't use them often, so I hope someone else can lend you a hand if that's what you're looking for 

Dec 17, 2012

Hayley P.

In black track ***

Dec 17, 2012

Caitlan F.

Stick: MAC (I think it's called Charcoal. It's $15.)
Liquid: Elf (Cheap && last all day)

Dec 17, 2012

Jackie M.

mark painted black liquid eyeliner. its awesome :)

Dec 17, 2012

Megan C.

Urban decay 24/7 LIQUED eye liner and maybe primer 

Dec 17, 2012

Avery M.

Maybelline eye studio gel. It's actually very good for a drug store liner.

Dec 17, 2012

Neidy R.

Sephora Eyeliner, or Lo'real Stiletto Eyeliner. 

Dec 17, 2012

Sofia L.

Milani! It's a dule

Dec 17, 2012

Manasi S.

right now im in love with the stilla felt tip liquid liner. it has a super thin tip and comes out dark

Dec 17, 2012

Elisha A.

Black track by mac gel liner x 

Dec 17, 2012

Alyse M.

Mac graphblack is my all time fav, cheaper ones I like the covergirl pencil with the smudger on one end and the elf felt tip liner.

Dec 17, 2012

Sarah C.

My favorite black eyeline of all time is the Dolly Wink black eyeliner pencil. It works so well in the water line and last forever on your eyes. 

Dec 17, 2012

Bridget M.

I've tried so many from high end to drugstore and my all time favorite is Revlon color stay.. It's not a pencil but gives great color and stays in place

Dec 17, 2012

Amanda B.

Thank you for all the suggestions guys! I have found with pencils in the past they don't go on dark at all. I have the gel one but I like the pencil cuz I feel like I have more control in applying it. I might have to switch to liquid. 

Dec 17, 2012

Megan M.

For pencil I do like urban decays but I've never had problems with it.. I also like urban decays liquid liner and hello kitty and revlon have nice felt liners. 

Dec 17, 2012

Chloe A.

Rimmel London kohl black jel eyeliner 

Dec 17, 2012

LaToya C.

Milani liquify eye 

Dec 17, 2012

Kimberly H.

I looooove tarte skinny smolder-eyes!!

Dec 17, 2012

Sierra C.

I am in fact in love/obsessed with the wet and wild creme eye shadow. Lasts ALL DAY without smudging or running(which is amazing considering my eyes run all day everyday guaranteed.) love love love & it's so incredibly cheap, it's redonk. 

Dec 17, 2012

Spencer B.

Lancôme!

Dec 18, 2012

Sophia L.

Pencil-
Mac

Liquid-
Revlon colour stay