What Has Been A Disappointment?

30

Sort By

Nov 22, 2012

Shelley W.

What product have you tried that received such rave reviews from everyone only to be a complete disappointment for you? I received a generous sample of Giorgio Armani's Maestro Liquid foundation and it was an epic failure for me.

Nov 22, 2012

Courtney B.

Smashbox primer. I absolutely hate any primer with a silicone feeling, and I don't think that it even works well enough for me to try to get used to the feeling. I also have been really underwhelmed by my NARS eyeshadow duos and trios, I feel like the pigmentation is really lacking and there's quite a bit of fallout. Speaking of NARS, I don't care much for Orgasm either. I love the peach + pink shades of it, but the glitter just really puts me off. I keep trying to make it work for me and it just is a no-go. What about that foundation was disappointing for you, Shelley?

Nov 22, 2012

Shelley W.

@Courtney B. the foundation was disappointing because it made no difference whatsoever in appearance. It just gave me a semi-matte look and husband actually said my skin looked way better naked without it than with this pricey stuff which is in the $60 dollar range. I didnt have to set it with powder since it dried to a powder finish but overall I was not impressed with it and I'm so glad he didnt get suckered into buying the full-size product at the counter. 

Nov 22, 2012

Rachael B.

Urban Decay Big Fatty mascara.

Nov 22, 2012

Rachael B.

Urban Decay Big Fatty mascara.

Nov 22, 2012

Yesenia P.

Laura Mercier Sill Cream foundation =\

Nov 22, 2012

Olivia B.

Not really a product but a tool, the MAC full eyelash curler is an overpriced thing of metal and you get a better result with a $2 drugstore one

Nov 22, 2012

Lexie M.

Sophora eye palette . It had almost no .pigmentation what so ever big dissapointment ! Drugstore eyesshadows are better I feel like!

Nov 22, 2012

Lexie M.

Sophora eye palette . It had almost no .pigmentation what so ever big dissapointment ! Drugstore eyesshadows are better I feel like!

Nov 22, 2012

Mae S.

I may be the only person to be disappointed with MUFE HD foundation. The finish was nice but it slipped right off my face within 2 hours. I wanted to like it so bad because there are sooo many great reviews on the foundation. 

Nov 22, 2012

Brittany S.

I have to second the smashbox primer. I also was disappointed with the too faced shadow insurance, my shadow held up better with out it. 

Nov 23, 2012

Marian H.

Bare mineral's foundation

Nov 23, 2012

Allyson W.

Rachael B I agree with you , big fatty mascara was a big disappointment to me

Nov 23, 2012

Cher W.

Too faced bad girl or bad gal mascara. I had better results with the L'oreal collagen mascara which costs less than half of,what the too face cost. Also cover girl eye shadow. 

Nov 23, 2012

Stephanie S.

Tarte Amazonian Clay Foundation. No matter what I use to apply it(Several different brush types, several different sponges and fingers), it just never works out well. I've also tried it with several different primers and without. I wanted it to work so bad. 

Nov 23, 2012

Violett J.

I hate hate hate Mac mascaras . I've purchased almost all attempting to fall in love but they're all so clumpy, thick and unflattering !!! 

Nov 24, 2012

Izabella B.

Maybelline mega plush!everyone raves about it but I think I don't like it because I don't like wet formulas.

Nov 24, 2012

Samantha P.

I hate Too Faced Shadow insurance and Smashbox's silicone primer.

Nov 24, 2012

Hermon G.

baby lips:(

Nov 24, 2012

Kendra C.

I definitly agree with the UD Big Fatty! I hated it! Also, I did not care for the Kat Von D Lock it concealer. For some reason it was not as full coverage as I thought it was going to be. :(

Nov 24, 2012

Shelley W.

@Stephanie S. Yes!!! The Tarte Amazonian Clay foundation did not work for me either. It my chin look gray/ashy. And I tried all sorts of tools to make it work. I even tried to blend it out with a regular liquid foundation. No dice. 

Nov 25, 2012

Shelley W.

I will actually need to take back what I said about the Giorgio Armani Maestro liquid foundation. My husband corrected me on application and its now actually a hit. 

Nov 25, 2012

Lucy R.

Maybelinne bb cream. Lightest color was way 2 tan 4 me. 

Nov 25, 2012

Amy B.

Maybelline bouncy blush. It is too oily and not much colour pay off

Nov 25, 2012

Jaimie M.

NARS Laguna illuminator cream- probaby just because of my skintone, but it made me look orange and Maybellines light BB cream- I didn't feel like it did anything at all.