Looking for a really pigmented YELLOW!

12

Sort By

Aug 23, 2011

Jacki C.

Hey beautylishers, I am in dyer need of your help. I have been on the hunt for a really pigmented MATTE yellow for a while and want your suggestions before I purchase.
x0 thanks lovers! 

Aug 23, 2011

Alyssa R.

Cheap or more pricey?

I've also been on the hunt for a pigmented matte yellow and can't find ANY drugstore.

For higher end, I've been on the fence between MAC and Sugarpill. MAC's Chrome Yellow is a matte yellow with more golden "undertone." About $15 at any MAC counter. I, personally, am leaning towards Sugarpill's Buttercupcake Pressed Shadow. It's just a gorgeously pigmented TRUE yellow. It's $12, only found online and you have to pay for shipping as well.

If I were to suggest to you, I'd tell you buy Sugarpill's Buttercupcake. It's just beautiful, hands down the best yellow I've seen. I think I just helped myself as well and will be purchasing soon. lol. Good luck. :)


Sugarpill's Buttercupcake:
http://www.sugarpillshop.com/products/buttercupcake-pressed-eyeshadow

MAC's Chrome Yellow:
http://www.maccosmetics.com/product/shaded/154/363/Eye-Shadow/index.tmpl


Alyssa
http://www.youtube.com/user/itslyssnicole

Jamie D.

Aug 23, 2011

Jamie D.

My favorite one is by Kryolan and I am a yellow freak. I have mac chrome yellow, NYX yellow funk, sugarpill. I swatch so many and pass, but I love the Kryolan one.

Aug 23, 2011

Amy R.

I'm looking for the same thing! I havent found one yet, but whatever you do, DO NOT buy the L'Oreal HIP duo in "Striking". Bad pigmentation, chalky formula, uneven application, ugh. It was absolutely horrible :( 

Aug 23, 2011

Jacki C.

thanks guys!! i really appreciate it! I have been eying Chrome Yellow by MAC for a while but I was curious to see if there were any others out there that were better! I might go for the sugarpill one! thanks ladies! 

Aug 23, 2011

Maria L.

Yellow (002) by Makeup Forever is a fantastically pigmented matte shadow. :-) 

Aug 23, 2011

Brianna G.

Definitely go for either Sugarpill's Buttercupcake or Makeup Forever's #2!

When I want to get a really vibrant yellow I usually pair my eyeshadow with a loose pigment on top. I start off with MAC's Chrome Yellow Eyeshadow and then I put MAC's Primary Yellow Pigment on top. I love how vibrant it becomes. :)

So if anything I would recommend using a yellow eyeshadow base and then add a yellow loose eyeshadow pigment on top to make it pop.

Aug 23, 2011

Jessica D.

Make up forever! It is the brightest yellow (matte) EVER!!! was just looking at it last night! 

Aug 24, 2011

Soma S.

I second Sugarpill!  

Andrea F.

Aug 25, 2011

Andrea F.

INGLOT YELLOWS CONQUER ALL.