Fave Drugstore-Brand Eyeshadow?

24

Sort By

Sep 26, 2010

Katie W.

Yes yes, MAC and Urban Decay are fabulous. But that doesn't mean there aren't treasures to be found in the local drug store for cheap! So what's your pick for "best drugstore eyeshadow"? I like the Revlon 12-hour colorstay quads - the pigment is good & the shadows are velvety. What about you?

I really like Maybelline Expert Wear and Eye Studio quads and Wet 'n Wild Color Icon quads. Both have good color pay off. 

I've had good experience with Maybelline EyeStudio & Expert Wear quads. For those of you in Canada - the Annabelle mono-shadows are nice too - I especially love the testers so you can try before you buy.

Sep 27, 2010

Jessica D.

I really love Loreal HIP Duos. I recently started to collect most of them. The duos have different finishes like matte, shimmer, satin, etc.. 

Sep 27, 2010

Elize M.

Hard Candy baked duos from Walmart are my fave. Most, I think all, are shimmer tho. But the colors are pretty and with primer they stay on all day and dont fade... 

Sep 27, 2010

Victoria S.

I love Milani eye shadows! Such great pigmentation and lots of MAC dupes :)

Oct 1, 2010

Romee H.

I agree with Melody, I been used Maybelline eye studio quads! Lovvvve it!  

Wet n Wild, NYX, HIP Duos are some of my faves.

NYX Cosmetics (in my opinion) is probably the best quality drugstore brand. The eyeshadows are well pigmented and their jumbo eye sticks are amazing!

Oct 3, 2010

Rai C.

NYX, Milani, L'Oreal HIP Duos, Maybelline, & Wet n Wild! 

NYX, wet n wild, hip duos, maybelline eye studio quads! :) 

Oct 12, 2010

Lala P.

Wet n Wild the new color icon palettes are super pigmented! 

Oct 12, 2010

Theresa L.

NYX- So highly pigmented! And has it so I can buy them in single colors without having to buy a set- I don't like the HIP because they are hard to get on the brush (even though they are gorgeous)?

Oct 13, 2010

Lacey H.

I really adore the Wet n Wild Color Icon palettes! :)

Oct 13, 2010

Lady P.

My fav drugstore eyeshadows would have to b the wetnwild quads and the Revlon Creme E/S

Oct 20, 2010

Meghan M.

Milani eyeshadows!! They're cheap and some are MAC dupes!
http://teaseandtweeze.blogspot.com/

Oct 20, 2010

Avi C.

I love the wet n wild as well as milani

Oct 20, 2010

Anna C.

Revlon 12-hour colorstay quads are amazing! And Maybelline Eye Studio Quads too... :)

Oct 20, 2010

Linzi F.

Milani & l'oreal wear infinite

Oct 21, 2010

Rai C.

L'Oreal HIP, NYX, Wet n Wild, and Milani. 

Oct 21, 2010

Tiffany J.

NYX ,Wet n Wild & HIP

Wet n wild new color icon

Oct 26, 2010

Nila J.

I've been stocking up on the Revlon matte shadows since the beginning of fall. Their Aubergine color is one of my faves!

Oct 26, 2010

Susana E.

I just bought some Wet n Wild Palettes and they are fab!
n_n

Oct 26, 2010

Yvette W.

HIP & NYX.