UD Anniversary Palette?

9

Sort By

Nov 2, 2011

Katy Mc P.

Hey, I was just wondering if people would recommend the Urban Decay 15th Anniversary Palette or the new Book of Shadows? I'd love to get both but as a broke college student I can only afford one!

Nov 2, 2011

Nina H.

I want the anniversary palette so bad. Im not so excite about the other new palette. The packageing is always amazing!

Nov 2, 2011

Jennifer M.

I would recommend the 15th Anniversary palette. The colors are gorgeous and the packaging is sleek. Although the colors on the book of shadows palettes are very nice as well, I personally don't care for the fuss on the packaging. The product itself on either one is great thoough.

Nov 2, 2011

Shelly T.

I don't own either of them, but if I had to pick one, it'd be the 15th Anniversary palette.

Nov 5, 2011

Katy Mc P.

Thanks gals! I definitely think i'll give the 15th anniversary palette a go =] 

Nov 5, 2011

Laura H.

I have both and I prefer the anniversary palette myself. More interesting colours and the packaging isn't so bulky!

Nov 5, 2011

Zoe C.

It depends what you like. The new book of shadows has a lot of muted autumn colours, whereas the 15th anniversary palette has a mix of brights and neutrals :) I want the 15th anniversary palette because of the brights :D

Deffinitly the UD 15th anniversary palette. Check out this review!

http://tluvzmakeup.blogspot.com/2011/09/urban-decay-15th-anniversary-eyeshadow.html

Nov 15, 2011

Jo S.

I'm going to agree with Jennifer. I saw it instore yesterday (I don't own it, but if the shadow quality is anything like the Naked palette, that's not anything to worry about) and the shades are gorgeous.

I think the frou-frou around the packaging is unnecessary (when you have a quality product, why do you need to invest so much in something like packaging?), but oh well.

I'll probably get it eventually...

Iam a big fan of urban decay I have almost all there palette I missed the first book of shadow and alice in wonderland but every other palette since then I have them all. From all the box of shadows to all the small sets ....if I have to pick one get the 15 anniversary you can not go wrong ...love it love love the only down side is that it picks up all the finger prints ...but who cares ... your in it for the eyeshadows right .I did a review when I had gotten mine check it out if you like ...you judge for yourself whats best for you ...hope it helps 

Jan 2, 2012

Katy Mc P.

Thanks for all your comments gals, I got it for Christmas and i'm so happy with it! The quality of the shadows are incredible and I love all the colours =] Its sorta annoying how the case picks up all the fingerprints but I was really impressed with the size of the mirror inside the lid!