mac or sugarpill

Oct 29, 2011

Brenda R.

well i was debating whether i should get some mac eyeshadows , but i've also really wanted to get the two sugarpill palettes since i've heard they have great pigmentation and have been looking for a vibrant red, yellow and orange. so to make up my mind i'll just ask my fellow beauties :) . what do you guys recommend i get  ?

Oct 29, 2011

Antonio Z.

I would say go with sugapill, cuz their pigmantation looks way better than mac's, but I guess is personal preference.
BTW you can get some MAC dupes here https://www.starsmakeuphaven.com/

Oct 29, 2011

DJ M.

I love, love my Sugarpill palette, I'd say go with those ;) You won't be disappointed!

Oct 30, 2011

Jasmine K.

i love my mac shadows like absoultely love BUT for the colors that your looking for i would go with sugar pill...especially since mac doesnt have a true to red eyeshadow...mac has a bright yellow, chrome yellow, and a bright orange, orange, if you really cant decide maybe get the yellow and orange from mac and the red from suarpill....then you know for future use which brand you like better

Oct 30, 2011

Brenda R.

thanks for the input, i think i'll probably get the sugarpill shadows :) 

Oct 30, 2011

Soma S.

I have both sugar pill palettes, and I suggest you watch Petrilude's vid review on it because I agree with everything he says. The yellow leaves something to be desired, and the white is a bit chalky, but is super pigmented. If you like those colors go for the sugar pill ones... But MAC has some great quality shadows depending on the finish/texture you select.

Oct 30, 2011

Jane A.

I once put Dollipop on my lids, and was too lazy to wash it all off. When I finally did, I swear my lids were "stained" from the pink.

But if you like bright - matte shadows Sugarpill hands down! The next time I use Sugarpill, I am going to wash it all off at the end of the night. 

Oct 30, 2011

Michelle D.

If you're looking for bright colored pigmentation, go with Sugar Pill. MAC, however, has a giant variety of shadows to choose from. Since you're looking for bright colors, Sugar Pill for sure.

Oct 31, 2011

Siri S.

depends ... I never really tried mac's red pigmented eyeshadows. BUT what I do know is that sugerpills is so awzume! And if you want to have a mat red eyeshadow sugar is the way to go, and if you want to have a more gliter you can buy the lose pigment :)

Oct 31, 2011

Keshonta B.

Well both ,Sugar pill has nice shadows in terms of pigmentation But Mac has a wide variety of colors where as sugar pill doesn't. Not everyone wears their makeup loud everyday. Both have something great to offer, its just according to what your looking for. 

Oct 31, 2011

Yasmin K.

Mac or Sugarpill? My vote is Sugarpill and here's why.

1. Pigmentation. Sugarpill products are FANTASTIC.
2. Price.

MAC eyeshadows are $15 (US) for 1.5 g / 0.05 oz.
Sugarpill pressed shadows are $12 for 4 grams / .14 oz..
You get more Sugarpill product for less money.

MAC pigments are $20 US ($24 CA) for 4.5 g / 0.15 oz.
Sugarpill loose shadows are $12 for 5 grams.
Again, Sugarpill you get more product for less money.