Which Too Faced Palette?

Apr 8, 2016

T K.

I want to buy my first Too Faced palette, but I am torn between 4 and I would love some help deciding! The ones I am thinking of are the chocolate bar, semi sweet, bon bons, and sweet peach. I am looking at pictures of all of them and they are so gorgeous. Sweet Peach stands out the most, but I am not sure if I would be better off with a palette with a bit more variety. I have hazel eyes and pale skin, which one would you recommend?

Apr 8, 2016

Lisa S.

The Sweet Peach looks pretty (and actually smells good too). I'm holding off on it though because I feel like I already other palettes with pink shades in it. Do not waste your money on the Semi-Sweet, it has bad reviews and anytime I've swatched it in stores its very chalky.

I actually bought the Chocolate Bar last week and I LOVE it! But I usually love any Too Faced eyeshadow. I find that the Chocolate Bar is more wearable for everyday because its neutral. And while Bon Bons is neutral too, the pinks in it don't always work for everyday, but its a beautiful palette. I got Bon Bons for Christmas and its easily one of my favorite palettes, and I have tons of eyeshadow palettes!

Apr 8, 2016

Anna I.

I vote for chocolate bar, It's the most wearable and a very good investment

Apr 8, 2016

T K.

Thank you ladies! Do you know if Sweet peach limited edition? That is one thing holding me back from buying the chocolate bar, simply because I know I could buy chocolate bar any time, but if sweet peach is le, I would hate to miss out!

Apr 8, 2016

Sabrina K.

I love my original chocolate bar palette so much! it's my most used palette for sure! it's so super versital and easy to work with! you can make neutral everyday looks and more glamorous looks! I honestly only have positive things to say about it! Next palette I am getting will be the bon bons, I'm so in love with that, but like you, I have been holding out because I know it's not limited edition! The semi sweet and sweet peach doesn't really call out to me, but if the sweet peach is one you like and is limited edi toi would definitely get that one, the 3 others are permanent and will always be available to you :)

Apr 8, 2016

Sabrina K.

I just went on the TF website and it says that the sweet peach is limited edition!

Apr 8, 2016

T K.

Thank you so much Sabrina! I didn't even think to check their website! I think I will go for Sweet peach then! I have friends going to the states that can bring it back to me, and then my next trip I can get the chocolate bar (and bon bons if I have the money XD)!

Apr 8, 2016

Stephanie G.

I much prefer my Bon Bon palette. the chocolate bar is pretty good as well. I never use my Semi-sweet.

Apr 8, 2016

Livi H.

My favorite is chocolate Bon Bons palette. Very pretty and can cater to all skin tones. It's not too warm toned, some shades lean a bit cool and some neutral.

I'm not fond of the original chocolate bar, it's very dusty and are very prone to fallout.

I also have the semi sweet, it's not chalky at all. It wears wonderfully, no fall out, easy to blend... Just like the Bon Bons. This palette has VERY warm tones and some shades lean super cool, not very much neutral toned. They are gorgeous colors though.

Apr 8, 2016

Alex M.

Sweat peach girl! The semi sweet is awful and if you like warm tones the sweet peach palette is perfect

Apr 9, 2016

Shelby M.

Either sweet peach or Bon Bon! Can't stand the semi sweet, waste of money.

Apr 9, 2016

Jamie L.

I own all of them except semi sweet because the colors just seemed way too warm for me and it's really nothing that special imo. I would say get the Bon bons. I absolutely love it. I reach for it every day even though I own a metric ton of eyeshadow. The sweet peach is nice as well, but I know once the newness of it wears off for me, I won't be using it as much as I am now. In all honesty the original chocolate bar is pretty, but I hardly ever use it. Even when I first bought it I didn't reach for it all the time. Don't get me wrong, there's some shades in there that I will pull out if I have a specific idea in mind, but the most practical every day palette for me has been the Bon Bons palette. It has a better mix of cool and warms than the others in my opinion. I felt like all the others leaned a little too warm. There are also more colors in the Bon Bons palette that I don't have anything similar to in my 7384672 others.

Apr 9, 2016

T K.

Thank you ladies so much :)

Apr 9, 2016

Marleen B.

I have & love the Original and had no interest in the Semi & Bon Bons because they seem like slightly cooler toned shades (which I don't prefer). But the Peach one is warmer and limited edition so I think I'm going to have to get it. IMO, I would get both. But if you can only get 1, get the Peach. It's limited edition, and if you don't get it, you may regret it. You can always get the original later.

Apr 9, 2016

Nicole A.

I'm probably the only one that feels this way but agh beauties don't hate me..I'm really not a too faced fan at all the only things I own are the 1st chocolate bar which I actually do adore and there glitter eye primer, everything else I've ever bought I've returned in my opinion I'm just not wowed by the brand at all with the exception of the 1st chocolate bar so I would say go with that one (:

Apr 9, 2016

T K.

Thank you ladies! It actually looks like I will get a gig (I am a freelance photographer) between now and when I purchase a palette, so maybe I can get both the original and sweet peach!! I appreciate your honesty Nicole!

Apr 10, 2016

Chassidy L.

I bought the Sweet Peach, and having hazel eyes, the purples in the palette really make the green in my eyes pop. It's nice, smells great, and blends wonderfully. I also have the chocolate palette, but I find myself reaching for this one, even above my z palette filled with ABH singles.

Apr 11, 2016

Abigail M.

I like my semi sweet chocolate bar the best just for the colors but all of them are amazing quality shadows so you should like anyone of them you pick.