Waterproof mascara battles

Apr 7, 2015

Livi H.

Have any of you ladies used the Tarte splashes mascara and/or Eyeko sport waterproof mascara? How did it perform for you and which did you like better?

Apr 7, 2015

Dawn C.

I have used both, I didn't like the brush or formula of Eyeko, as a lover of Tarte I love everything about it, formula wand and it comes off using purity. I hope this helps a little. :)

Apr 7, 2015

Alexis C.

I absolutely love the Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes! Great formula and very long wearing (:

Apr 7, 2015

Livi H.

Oh really? What was the formula of the eyeko like? I'm really interested since I can't find any reviews of the sport one.

Apr 7, 2015

Livi H.

Thank you Alexis. Its great to hear that you both love the tarte splashes. That is what I had originally in my Ulta Cart but then I saw the Eyeko ones lol!

Apr 7, 2015

Isabella K.

Tarte is absolutwly amazing. It made my eyelashes grow loads and it makes them look so beautiful.

Apr 7, 2015

Livi H.

I agree Isabella, I do have the original tarte 4in1 lashes mascara and I absolutely love it. I am just wondering how true the waterproof version holds up to its claim compared to the Eyeko waterproof

Apr 7, 2015

Monica K.

I have (almost) all day watery eyes and the Tarte water proof holds up with no problems.

Apr 7, 2015

Livi H.

Ooh that's good! I think I will end up getting the tarte. It's cheaper too! Lol gosh the Eyeko is like 24 dollars!