Best Maybelline Mascaras?

24

Sort By

Jan 13, 2013

Paisly H.

I am planing on getting a new maybelline (I may be spelling that wrong...) mascara soon. I am deciding between the "Colossal" mascara, the "Mega Plush, or the "Clump Crusher" mascara. I already have very long thick eyelashes, so it doesn't really matter in that way; it just matters in quality. Which one do you prefer? Also, I am open to any other mabelline mascaras :))

Jan 13, 2013

Brooke E.

I personally hate Maybelline mascaras. The formula is so wet and I always had to wipe off the product at the end of the wand because they really don't know how to make a stopper. I have a tube from maybe nine months ago to see if it would dry out. It still hasn't.

Jan 13, 2013

Taylor J.

Mega Plush!

Jan 13, 2013

Marissa C.

All

Jan 13, 2013

Brianna A.

Personally, I really like the Great Lash Mascara! First mascara I ever bought and I still use it, I use others as well but I always buy it if there isn't any new mascara's out. Haha. I dunno. I just love it. However The Great Lash Mascara is a wet formula. If you aren't looking for that, try Maybelline's Falsies. I found that one the least wettest of mascara formulas. 

Jan 13, 2013

Jadira M.

Falsies, one by one

Jan 13, 2013

Brianne D.

Illegal length is my fave! But I also like mega plush, and great lash. Colassal didn't work for me. It just flaked and ended up all over my cheeks by the end of the day

Jan 13, 2013

Sara K.

I've been using the Great Lash mascara for about a year now and I really like it! It is a wet formula mascara, but it dries quickly once it is on your eyelashes. 

Jan 13, 2013

Amanda S.

Maybelline lash stiletto is amazing

Jan 13, 2013

Madison M.

I just got One by One and Falsies Drama. Love them both!

Jan 13, 2013

Kara S.

Great Lash w the curved brush

Jan 13, 2013

Julia L.

I would go for mega plush. My sister has it and she says that it is really good. I have the cat eye one and I like that one the most

Jan 13, 2013

Ali T.

Falsies definitely. But if youre looking for a wet formula, the mega plush is great. But it does have a wiggly wand, which i found difficulty with but yeah hope this helps.

Jan 13, 2013

Brianna B.

Big and Bold NYC. It's In a pink & green tube:)

Jan 13, 2013

Joselin T.

meqaplush or illeqal lenqth ❤

Jan 13, 2013

Melissa S.

One by one works great! Love the brush so much, very volumizing and lengthening. 

Jan 13, 2013

Jalaina S.

Lash stiletto, falsies, & Cat Eye are my favorites. Didn't care for Mega Plush.

Jan 13, 2013

Mareah J.

Has anybody tried the new Rocket stuff by Maybelline besides Lauren? I really want to get it, but I always need feedback before I buy something :) looks good so far!

Jan 13, 2013

Maggie D.

The rocket by far

Jan 13, 2013

Brittney L.

I personally love the Rocket and Mega Plush or u could go with illegal lenght!!!

Jan 13, 2013

Rebecca G.

I would say the new rocket one from maybelline :) 

Jan 13, 2013

Jillian K.

I just tried the rocket! I love it one coat makes my lashes so long! 

Jan 13, 2013

Natty G.

I like Falsies, i dont count how many time i bought this mascara ... Love it 

Jan 13, 2013

Paisly H.

I think I might try Rocket, Illegal Length, or Mega Plush! Thanks guys! Anymore? :))

Jan 13, 2013

Jennifer N.

Illegal length!