Reviews
Sadly Disappointed
I've been hearing about Stila liquid eyeliner for ages and I was really excited to finally try it for myself, so I am really disappointed with my experience. It went on almost transparent and was hardly buildable because whenever I tried to go over the same line twice, it just took the product right off like a dry erase marker or something.
I like how fine the lines are, but the watery consistency and lack of pigment made wing tips impossible. A couple hours after applying my makeup, I brushed my eye with a finger and the product crumbled off and disappeared. I didn't even need soap or makeup remover to wash it off. Just a little water. Everyone else has such good experiences with Stila eyeliner that I just don't know what to think. Maybe I just got a messed up batch?