Stila

Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

Reviews

Grace H.
Great but not what I was looking for

It has great pigment and it stays on all day without smudging. I’ve got relatively oily lids (waterproof mascaras often transfer a bit to my eyelids). However, this stayed on all day without budging. However, it was not what I was looking for. I like to draw the thinnest lines for eyeliner and this won’t allow me to draw as thin as I’d like. The photos online just looked like it would draw thinner lines than it does in real life. Great for general eyeliner purposes, though.

1 found this helpful.
Serena K.
can't get anything better!!

By far the best eyeliner i have ever used!! last all day and night, smudge free, water proof, easy to apply. perfect to make a simple line or add a flare at the end. i would defiantly recommend!

Sckye Y.
Good product minus the packaging

Liked the product - highly pigmented, application is smooth and easy, and it stays superbly looooong. However the packaging is kind of cheap and tacky. Once you take out some length of the product, you can never take it back. The cover is terribly fragile - you can have little cracks if you push it even just a little too hard onto the smudge stick. I was very very cautious and careful at first until I dropped it and got the cover cracked anyway (on both tips - boo!). This thing is quite pricey for a pencil eyeliner, hope Stila can somehow upgrade the packaging. One cannot perform a quick makeup with fragile products such as these.