Reviews
I got this liner because my local Ulta was out of Maybelline's waterproof/smudgeproof cream liner pencil. I think that this is an ok liner. I say that it's ok because it's not waterproof, so it does not work well for the waterline. I also think the black could be a bit more pigmented. It works great for outlining a cat eye then filling it in with black shadow. I'm just not all that impressed with this product.