Rock 'N' Kohl

It's soft and goes on smoothly but didn't even last a half hour in my waterline. I tried it multiple times on days where I wasn't doing anything at all, and it didn't last even 30 minutes. Just a waste of money relying on its name.

Best eye cheat ever! It went on smooth and lasted for hours. Unfortunately I had to return it because it irritated my eyes.

Although I love Charlotte Tilbury eye pencils, this one is a pass. I just does not stay on my waterline/inner rim. This isn't a problem that I've had with any of her other pencils.

I have been searching for the perfect nude eyeliner for my waterline; and Charlotte Tilbury's version is superb. It is soft, pigmented and does not irrirtate my eyes. I didn't think it would last throughout the entire day on the waterline. But each time I have worn it it has survived 100+ degree weather for 8 hrs or more!

On a side note, I love that the barrel of the pencil is a high quality wood--it smells SO good.

I was a little worried about this product, to be honest, the color on the pencil and the swatches look pretty dark compared to what I'm used to. (FTR I have somewhere between an NC20/25 skin tone). I always use a light flesh toned or white pencil in my water line to make my eyes look more awake, and have been using an inexpensive drug store brand for years, because I figured most nude toned pencils were the same. I've been such a fool. Not only did this pencil brighten up my eyes beautifully, it lasted ALL DAY. I got a solid 10 hours of wear from this, I didn't think that was possible. I was stunned. This kohl pencil is well worth the money, and has achieved holy grail status in my makeup case, its top shelf all the way!!!

I love this. my new fave! it lasts long even in humidity and it stays on black throughout the day.

This is, hands-down, the best eye pencil I've ever used- period. The pigmentation is incredible, it's super creamy and lasts all day without budging, which is quite a feat for an inner-rim pencil. I can't wait to buy the other colors!

I bought this eyeliner specifically for the colour, however now that I've actually used it, I'm buying one in each of the other colours because I love it so much! Glides on smoothly, almost like it's liquid in a pencil shape, is very pigmented (one swipe with a light hand is all that's necessary) and stays put on my waterline. I'm throwing out all my other liners once the other colours come in!

Will never leave the house without swiping Eye Cheat on my lower lash line. Instant and subtle pick-me-up. So worth it and the pencil will likely last a long time. Buy it!!

I hate wearing black Kohl everyday so I like to where like white cream colours. This Charlotte Tilbury one is great for me and stays put. Especially because I don't wear eyeliner everyday and this colour just make you look awake.