Rock 'N' Kohl

I have switched completely to clean beauty, but have to say that CT has the best eye and lip makeup that conventional makeup can offer. This eyeliner stays put once set, but it is very creamy and can be diffused too. Great colors.

I have ridiculously sensitive eyes and multiple sclerosis so my health and time are so important. This didn't irritate my eyes at all, even in my waterline which was massive for me because I love the look but most liners do irritate me. This isn't even meant for using there but wow she has high standards because it works well and was comfortable for my sensitive eyes. Although I wish I could more easily afford it, I find it worth the money and I only use it in the waterline to conserve it.

Charlotte Tilbury products are so hit or miss for me. Half I adore, half I don't know why I tried. I like this as it goes on very, very smooth and doesn't smudge or flake off underneath your eyes. I've worn it in the Miami humidity and barely had to wipe where it would get on my upper eye and underneath my eye (I usually just skip eyeliner, even though I love it, because it just melts). For a soft pencil (I prefer felt or liquid for cat eye) this is one of my fav I've found so far. While I don't reach for it all the time, it definitely does the job and stays put surprisingly well for how creamy it is!

This product is OK but not a product that is “I have to have it”. The product glides on and the pigment is great but it does fade easy on lower lash line especially if you suffer from allergies. On the top lash life span is a bit longer. A beautiful product but nothing that is special.

This is the best eyeliner I have ever bought. Very precise, pigmented, and doesn’t dry out or flake. Recommend buying the Charlotte Tilbury pencil sharpener to keep pencil length longer. Thank you Shanon for packaging my order! :)

I am Asian with eyes that fold inward and I put this on as soon as I received it and less than10 mins it smudged. I really had high hopes for it. It did go on really smooth. I was hoping to find non liquid waterproof eyeliner, guess this isn’t totally smudge proof.

Okay...so it is BLACK and very smooth my only complaint is that you do not get very much product. Also the tip broke the first time I used it. I will not be repurchasing this product

I am stoked about this wonderful eyeliner! It is everything it promises to be and more. I happen to live in sunny, hot, and humid Texas and today was the first day I dared apply the eyeliner, expecting the same old experience: it would hold for about an hour and slowly move to my creases beneath my eyes but with this eyeliner, I was pleasantly surprised! It not only glided on, but stayed on after about 6 hours of running errands, dinner and now! I am a 40+ woman with mature/combo skin and despite all this, the eyeliner held on! This eyeliner holds as good as my KVD trooper liquid eyeliner and I am giving it a five star and above rating!

Now I have many eye liners. Some liquid, some gel, some pencil. I mainly own chanel, Dior, Bobbi brown. I have a fantastic gel by Mary Kay believe it or not. Charlotte Tilbury is a hit or miss. This is one of her biggest hits!! Out of all my eye liners, this is the blackest black. I can't even believe it. I saw in some reviews that it smudged on some. I did not find that. I found it was the only one I owned that didn't move. AND it stayed for HOURS. In perfect condition!! I'm in love. It also glides on like nothing I've ever seen before. Best eye liner out there.

I have used a bunch of different products trying to get a good dark color for my waterline and have something that stays put. This is a great rich black, easy to use, and it doesn't move! I was farming in the rain the other day and I got home to still have the eyeliner perfectly in place.

It is worth every cent.