this stuff is fantastic! but I can honestly say it is not the best smelling stuff I've used when it comes to eye makeup remover. Very gentle on the eyes and took all mascara and anything I put on my eyes that day.
I'm purely judging it on the smell, I purchased eos balm about 2 weeks ago and I haven't used it yet as I'm finishing off my Palmers stick. it smells fantastic but I hope it's as good as it smells.