im a in love with these eye liners, they are amazing!
they're long lasting, very pigmented. they don't smudge at all. and tbh they're quite inexpensive, 3 of them are for about $13, which is quite cheap.
i highly reccomend these.
i really did not liker the cheek tints. i did end up returning it. its not very pigmented and quite oily. and I'm not a huge fan of the colour combinations.
id pass on this product,
AMAZING COVERAGE! very inexpensive, but great quality. highly recommend it. not many shades offered, but luckily i found my colour.
if you happen to see this at walmart, don't pass, buy it ;)