The Waterproof Mascara

This is the best mascara by far! The only one I will ever use! My lashes look amazing after every use!

This doesn’t work for me. I find it smudges on my lower lash line. A lot of mascaras do but not expected from a waterproof one. It doesn’t add a lot of length or volume. It does do a nice job of separating the lashes and is never clumpy. I actually appreciate that in a waterproof mascara that I plan to wear to the beach on light makeup days but, as I said, it smudges. I am a Wayne Goss fan but I won’t repurchase this one.

The only mascara that not only give you the best glam, but can also withstand vigorous winter sport days. The only caveat is, you need a good eye-makeup remover.

I've tried a LOT of mascara because I'm picky and have a lot of allergies. This is hands down my favorite. I have long lashes and most mascaras weigh them down after I curl them. This does not. My lashes stay curled all day long. I'm not sure why other people are experiencing smudging because it doesn't smudge on me and I have relatively oily lids. It is difficult to remove if you don't use an eye makeup remover but I found one that works well for me (CeraVe Comforting Eye Makeup Remover). Definitely recommend.

I have been on the hunt for a waterproof mascara that does not smear when applied to the lower lashes. I like heavy liner and mascara and that is not always easy to achieve without the products smudging on to my eyelids and bleeding down to my undereyes. The mascara I was using changed formulas so I have been testing tons. This one is my new holy grail. The small wand head makes it super easy to apply to both top AND bottom lashes and the waterproof mascara makes this mascara BUDGE PROOF. this mascara is. not. moving. with that being said, i do recommend removing this product with a balm or oil of some sort. :)

I’m honestly really jealous of the good reviews. Don’t get me wrong, this mascara looks great on eyelashes. Separates and everything. HOWEVER it smudges under my eye and above my eye, even after it’s dry. I can’t support a mascara that wears like that unfortunately, especially with hooded eyes. I found it all very strange as normally waterproof mascaras don’t smudge like that. Again… it’s beautiful, but just doesn’t wear like it should for me.

I’ve always loved waterproof for mascara because it holds the curl so well. Normally after a while my eyes start getting irritated, but not with this one! And I work 12 hour shifts so I need it to last my whole shift and this one does! It doesn’t smudge, flake or irritate my eyes. And it’s easily removable with a cleansing oil or cleansing balm. I will continue to repurchase this over and over. Please don’t ever stop making this!!

Panda eyes, even on days where I spent the entire day in an air conditioned environment. It needs the help of a mascara brush to brush out clumps and even out lashes. Tough to remove as well. Didn’t work for me unfortunately.

I LOVE this mascara. I very long eyelashes, naturally. Very often I’ll put on a mascara that ends up on my upper eyelids, because there is too much on the wand. Additionally, I have oily eyelids, so whatever didn’t stay on my lashes would melt onto my upper and lower eyelids throughout the day. Wayne Goss’s Waterproof Mascara checks all the right boxes for me! When I pull out the wand there is just enough product to coat my lashes and not my upper eyelids. Thank you, Wayne!

I bought two when they first released as I believe in Wayne’s products. I have been using Kevin A for years but thought a waterproof mascara would be a nice change. I was wrong. The wand is great but please release a tubular version that can be easily removed. No matter how well I think I’ve removed the mascara, I wake up the next day with Panda eyes. I also get Panda eyes later in the day I’m wearing the mascara.