Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used! It goes on soooo smoothly and stays on all day! Rue Bonaparte is so gorgeous on the waterline and brightens my eye beautifully without being too much (like a white color would). I use this color almost every day.

This is amazing. It is purely smudge proof and when I wipe my eyes, I had non come off at all. I purchased it from Sephora and it was worth the money. I use this perfect product every day!

One of the best eyeliner I have ever used. You have to let it dry 30 seconds and then it doesn't smudge. Love it. May splurge on other colors.

I have long struggle with eye liners since i have oily lids, some of them will be O.K. but at the end just not good enough.This eyeliner is just deep black and draws perfect lines that stay in place. But what's really amazing is the sharpener at the end! Such genius and useful little thing. I can even line the water line of my upper lashes and it wont smudge, simply a great product.

I was looking for a flesh-colored eye liner pencil for my waterline to look more awake. I owned a cheap white eyeliner, but the contrast was fake looking. I came across this at Sephora and I love it, of course. The color is a yellow toned beige, which suits me just fine. The pencil itself is smoothe, creamy, and pigmented, exactly what you'd expect from a $23 eyeliner. It definitely lives up to its claim of being long-wearing, for the most part. Its glides nicely on the waterline and doesn't tug of irritate my eyes much. I like having eyeliner on my waterline, but I have very sensitive eyes, so I hardly put any liner on my waterline because of that. So I appreciate that I can wear this without feeling like there's poison on my eyeballs. :)

Can we just talk about how amazing these pencils are? Not only do they apply like a dream, but they last all day on my slightly oily lids. The only downside (and the reason for docking 1/2 a star): the weird sharpening system. If you're not careful you'll lose a lot of product. My advice? Don't use the smaller sharpener attached to the end of the pencil, just hold it at an angle. Oh, and it's a twist up pencil-- DO NOT try to us a regular sharpener on it!