Reviews
I wanted to love this but it smudges like crazy
I've tried very hard to love this product but sadly, we're just not meant to be. It takes all of one hour for this to smudge on my eyes and leave a mess of black liner all over the place. There are many better liners out there on the market, give this a pass.
Worth it, great for oily lids!
I took a gamble on this during the gift card event and it paid off! I've heard good things about the Makeup atelier brand itself, but couldn't find any reviews about the eyeliner. I've been wearing this on unprimed eyes for over 10 hours, and normally I get transfer marks on my eyelids as I have very oily skin. But this hasn't moved at all. I've taken off a star for personal preference (I prefer pen style eyeliners, and you need to wipe off the excess on the brush) and that while this is black on the first coat , you need a second coat if you want it super dark.