Fluidline

I've tried L'oreal, to elf, to Bobbi Brown, and figured I would purchase this because of its high ratings. I bought it and I was not impressed. Didn't go on that black for me, which is the main reason I choose gel liner over a pencil. I will never purchase this again.

I have both deliciously rich and black track. I love the formulation and the "gel"ish substance, the only downside is that it smudges a lot after 3 1/2 to 4 hours. Deliciously rich is soo beautiful, with gold sparkles in a dark brown "gel". I feel like the black track smudges more than d. Rich.

I apply this with a fine liner brush by RealTechniques and it goes on so smoothly and creamy! It's a really easy gel liner to use and it is so pigmented. I got it in the colour 'Blacktrack' and this colour is truly black. Its so pigmented, a little goes a long way. After about 5 seconds it dries so you can't rub it off, it stays put all day until you put makeup remover on it!

I'm not sure I'll ever use another eyeliner! I bought the 219 eyeliner brush to go with this and the color is so black and smooth! It stays on all day, waterproof, creamy, sharp. This is the best eyeliner! It's like a tattoo until you use makeup remover! Absolutely the best. Makes for perfect wings.

My eyeliner has never been this black! I always searched for a really black eyeliner and this one is so black and fits so good, at the end of the day it still looks so perfect! I use it with the 219 brush from Mac!

This was my first gel liner I ever tried and so far it's stayed that way. I was skeptical just cause of my liquid liner comfort zone but I'm so glad I tried it. It glides on during application like butter. To apply it I use Sephora's must have angled liner 90. The only thing I found was that you must set it with a black eyeshadow otherwise it'll dry out and lose it's color throughout the day. Nothing you can't fix though.

Love this easy to use the price is worth it very effective. true to its color would love to purchase another shade and a lot is not needed drys quickly and great for winged look.

Best gel liner ive tried. Id recommend for those that have a hard time lining their eyes. It also lasts quite a while. I have tried black and purple and they are awesome

I recently purchased this gel eye liner, and I have to say that I am in love!! It is so creamy and smooth! It is super easy for my to do a winged cat eye, The eye liner is bendable , super black and it lasted me all day. I would definitely repurchase and maybe in other colors too. I would probably get Dipdown, which is good for nice neutral look

To apply I use Sigma E05 brush, If your eyeliner smudges I recommend to set the eye liner with a black eye shadow especially if you have oily lids.

The fluid lines from Mac has an easy-to-use formula, I could have been more liquid. Sadly it smudges a bit. The color I chose is glamour is and a bit ordinary. Love the colors!