Waterproof Cushion Liner

Will I ever find a water proof eyeliner that doesn't turn flakey and crust off? This surely did not fit the bill. Disappointing

I bought the Night Walk shade of this on an impulse. This is not a good liner for the waterline but for the lash line it is fabulous! It wears for 12 hours plus with no fading, smudging or flaking and the color is gorgeous. I like that it is a liquid liner in a pot with the sponge pad because I can control the amount of liner on the brush and there is less mess than the pen style makeup brush.

I purchased this in the color "Blue Jay." The color was far less vibrant in person than it had seemed in the online swatch - nowhere near cobalt, far closer to a sort of bluey teal. I was willing to blame monitors for that. However, even that color required multiple coats to fully show up, and by the time it did, the bottom coat(s) were moving around. Not to mention that it is SO watery, that it never seems to actually set - by the time it does (sort of) set, it's already moved around. (Also, even when it "sets" - a light swipe is all it takes to dislodge the color.) I find it bizarre that it claims to be waterproof, and it isn't even touch-proof.

Perhaps a professional MUA would follow this up with a matching powder to set . . . honestly, I don't know. I was so excited to try these and I am honestly shocked at the quality. Why anyone would choose these over a gel (or even just an eyeshadow) is beyond me. Maybe I got a bad batch?

I have purchased a million different eyeliner that I hoped would stay on my eyes and I haven’t found any until now!!! Why didn’t I find this sooner It’s so easy to apply and it lasts until I remove it!!!! I have never found anything that didn’t smudge or run and this absolutely doesn’t!!! This eyeliner is now a must have in my make up kit!!!! I love it!!!!!!

I usually use gel liner but haven't been able to find one that's a true navy, so I decided to try this. The formula is very thin and almost watery so it does take two coats to get full opacity, but that's my only issue, and it's minor. I apply this with a very thin angled brush and once it sets, it doesn't budge until I remove it. It doesn't peel, flake or fade throughout the day. I'm also very happy with the color as it's the matte deep inky navy that I've been searching for and it definitely makes my dark brown eyes pop. The color selection is great and includes many that just aren't found in typical gel liners. Definitely recommend.

Usually I'm not a big fan of cushion products. Yet, this eyeliner has become my new favorite whether a natural thin line or full on wings. Once applied it doesn't move, easy to apply with my Wayne Goss brush. I like the idea of the cushion as I find it seems like I am only removing the amount of product I need for my application.

I also purchased Cloud Control and Night Walk. I am in love with this line from the liners to the ColorFix to the Enlight Powders to the foundations. Let me stop, I'm a little obsessive.

I love the colour. However I'm not a fan of the sponge pad which holds the pigment, it takes a bit of effort to get onto my brush. Definitely prefer Inglot gel eyeliners over this!