Best Gel Or Cream Liner?

Dec 18, 2012

Lyndsey R.

I just bought the MUFE Aqua Cream Eyeliner. It's my first liner that I've applied with a bush; I normally use the Lineur Intense liquid liner with the felt tip.

I'm not sure how I feel about this liner. It's not as creamy or as wet as I hoped. What did those of you who have tried thus think of it? Is there a better one out there at a similar price.

Dec 18, 2012

Virginia M.

i just use the elf cream liner. IT IS SUPER BLACK and the other colors pop. Its only 3 $$ i think and its amazing. I use it with target brand liner brush :)

Dec 18, 2012

Ashley D.

ELF cream liner good for drugstore but hight I use smash box or Mac gel liner

Dec 18, 2012

Neens C.

High end - Bobbi brown gel eyeliner in espresso ink! Be warned though that in my opinion I've never seen a gel eyeliner in a pot that's 'wet' like - if that's what you're looking for you might wanna stick with liquid! But I do love my Bobbi brown - it gives a slightly softer look than liquid :)

Dec 18, 2012

Michelle D.

MAC fluidline in Black track 

Dec 18, 2012

Stacey L.

Mac fluidline . By far the best in pigmentation and lasts all day. I never ever have to touch up

Dec 18, 2012

Shelley W.

I love my Bobbi Brown gel liner but it doesn't dry into a glossy finish. Like Neens C mentioned its a much softer look than liquid.

Dec 18, 2012

Leighanne B.

Wet n wild cream eyeliner !! 2.99 , AMAZING. Doesn't smudge like the elf one does and it never cracks , it is amazing and my go to!

Dec 19, 2012

Elayna Y.

Bobbi Brown eyeliner is the best! It has never failed me even through the craziest workouts.